Call us at 516.481.7636
Please allow one week for custom cake orders.


At Riesterer’s we pay special attention to your symbolic centerpiece – the cake. As a baking family for over 93 years, we have participated in our fair share of celebrations. However, each one is special to us and we are especially honored when we are invited to create the crowning jewel of your celebration. With our team of professionals, our history as Long Island’s oldest bakery, and the receipt of various awards for our superb products, we believe we are qualified to make your special occasion shine.

We hope that you will entrust us with your next custom cake or sweet ending; we are sure that we will live up to your expectations and add to the success of your celebration. Explore our site to see some of the baked goods we offer. Have questions or need more information? You can call 516.481.7636 and speak with one of our experienced sales associates. We also encourage you to stop in at the bakery to see our products in person.